July 3, 2008

Unity in Defense of the Supreme Court of Justice and Against Impunity and the Populist Dictatorship

Written by Senator Jorge Enrique Robledo*, 30 June 2008.
Translated from Spanish by Dawn Paley and Michèal Ó Tuathail

As what had been prepared for days before, President Álvaro Uribe responded with the usual smokescreen to the carefully substantiated decision of the Penal Court of the Supreme Court of Justice, which condemned Yidis Medina for accepting a bribe. The court found that the Congress member had committed the crime of selling her vote to pass the law that would eventually pave the way for presidential re-elections in Colombia, from which the current head of state directly benefited. Álvaro Uribe’s shameless aggression against the Supreme Court of Justice, unprecedented in the history of this country, has the obvious intention of deceiving Colombians and pressuring attorneys and judges into absolving high-level government functionaries accused of buying the vote of Yidis Medina; functionaries who, like Ambassador Sabas Pretel and Minister Diego Palacios, are already under investigation by the Attorney General for a list of charges. Álvaro Uribe is hence repeating the tactic of attempting to discredit and intimidate the Supreme Court of Justice, a tactic that he has used since the day the court began to establish with civil validity the judicial truth about para-política [a scandal linking Colombian politicians to collusion with paramilitary death squads], a case in which 85 per cent of the more than 60 parliamentarians implicated in the scandal are Uribe-supporters.

After noting “the crime cannot generate any type of constitutional or legal legitimacy,” the Penal Court of the Supreme Court of Justice wisely transferred its verdict on the Yidis Medina case to the Constitutional Court, “for ends deemed advisable,” given that the law that was passed authorized the current president’s possibility for re-election. Paradoxically, it is worth noting that Álvaro Uribe, in the bald-faced break with institutional order that he has promised to maintain, confirmed that which has already been established in the Constitution and in law: the illegitimacy of his re-election, based on a law that was approved through a criminal act, one of which the only remaining question is the nature of the charges faced by the members of his government who were also involved in the bribe.

Moreover, there is the extremely grave decision of Álvaro Uribe to take another step towards tyranny by breaking down the separation of powers defined by the Constitution as a minimum democratic guarantee, a path he has pursued since he decided to run for re-election and dismantle the system of constitutional control among the branches of public power. Putting aside the polls that Uribe supporters use to justify the worst abuses, the imposition of the dictatorship consists of placing the totality of the state under the command of just one person. One must now recall how Hitler and Mussolini justified the horrors they perpetrated by citing massive support from Germans and Italians.

In his authoritarian logic, Álvaro Uribe has also decided to oppose Yidis Medina’s conviction by holding a referendum calling for a “repeat” and legitimization of the 2006 presidential elections. No quantity of votes can change a legal ruling or convert something corrupt into something honest. It is outrageously irresponsible to provoke a serious institutional crisis and write off enormous problems in order to carry out a referendum and another election so that Uribe can govern, as is currently established, until 2010. Given the aforementioned, we are presented with two possibilities: either Uribe and his supporters are hiding their other objectives, such as once again changing the Constitution to impose a new re-election, by means of exchanging something especially gruesome and damaging for something disproportionately worse; or there has been an error in calculation that Álvaro Uribe could finally be forced to rectify. Facing his downfall, he will have to reconcile citizens’ resistance and the demands of the powers upon which his luck has depended, those who have already expressed their rejection of his latest foolish act.

It is without a doubt that, no matter how things turn out, the latest craftiness of Álvaro Uribe and the clique that surrounds him, through the instability and image of the country they have generated and projected, is causing great damage to the country, especially given that the winds of a national and international economic crisis are mounting. Faced with another delusional tirade from the self-styled Messiah, the following question arises: What limits will you not break as you are further discredited?

As it was duly proposed by Carlos Gaviria, President of the Polo Democrático Alternativo [Colombia’s primary opposition party], “Now is the time for all democratic sectors (social and political) in the country to come to the defense of what little of our democracy we have left. We must rally behind our courts and scream will all the force of our voice that Uribe must not continue to govern the country to preserve his impunity and impose a populist dictatorship.”

Bogotá, June 30, 2008.

*Jorge Enrique Robledo is a Colombian Senator from the opposition Polo Democrático Alternativo (Alternative Democratic Pole) party.

July 2, 2008

Statement from Pueblos en Camino on the Release of Ingrid Betancourt

Written by the Pueblos en Camino Collective,
Originally published in Pueblos en Camino, 2 July 2008

WE REJOICE, WITH THOSE LIBERATED, THEIR FAMILIES AND FRIENDS AND CALL THEM TO USE THEIR FREEDOM TO ACHIEVE THAT OF ALL COLOMBIANS


Colombia's Minister of Defense has just announced that former Presidential Candidate Ingrid Betancur, together with three American Soldiers and 11 members of the Colombian Armed Forces held by FARC have been rescued unharmed in a successful operation carried out by Colombian intelligence disguised as representatives of a "fake" NGO who were to transfer them under the orders of FARC's Secretariat. As this note is written, the Minister says they are being transferred by air to a military base (Tolemaida) near Bogotá. Ingrid has been in captivity for 6 years and 4 months.


We share in rejoicing on these news and hope all others will be released promptly. As we celebrate the successful operation and their freedom, we await further news and hope that this happening promotes not only the liberation of all those kidnapped, but also the necessary
mobilizations in order to free Colombians as a whole from the social injustice and corruption that has lead to so much suffering and hatred.


Our feelings of affection go to the families and friends of those liberated and to the relatives and friends of those who remain in captivity, as well as to the millions of victims of systematic terror exercised by the establishment and by all those who use force for their benefit.


Until everyone is free and there is justice, we cannot forget or forgive. May the freedom and joy of Ingrid and the other 14 people that have been rescued unharmed help all of us to bring freedom to Colombia!


May our collective actions bring peace with justice at last! In the midst of our joy we must state firmly: NO LIBERATION WILL ENDURE UNTIL IT IS GRANTED TO ALL WITHIN A JUST SOCIETY. In celebration and commitment we express these feelings and share the joy and good news. To us, this momentous event constitutes an invitation to mobilize until there is
freedom and justice in Colombia for all.

What Ottawa Didn't Tell You About the Colombia FTA

Written by Augusto Bohorquez, Originally published in Rabble, 2 July, 2008
Translated by La Chiva Collective

On June 7, 2008, on the official webpage of Canada's Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade, a press release with the following title appeared: "Canada Concludes Negotiations of Free Trade and Labour and Environmental Cooperation Agreement with Colombia."

Curiously, said negotiations occurred without the knowledge of the vast majority of Canadians and Colombians. Canadian Minister of Foreign Affairs and International Trade, David Emerson, said that this agreement "will help to solidify the efforts of the Colombian government to create a more secure, prosperous and equitable democracy."

This leads one to ask what kind of democracy Emerson is referring to, since these agreements are negotiated in complete secrecy and behind the backs of the citizens of both countries.

With this kind of democracy, Canada is showing the world that it supports one of the most illegitimate regimes on the face of the planet. This has been a well known fact since the first election of Colombian President Álvaro Uribe Vélez, which was obtained thanks to the territorial control of paramilitary groups, a widely acknowledged and documented scandal known as "parapolítica," or paramilitary politics.

Moreover, the Colombian Constitution was modified in 2006 in order to reelect Uribe to a second term, a process that depended on the decisive vote of Colombian House Representative Yidis Medina, who changed her vote at the last minute in favour of the government (according to her own confession given to the parliament through her testimony before the Colombian Supreme Court). Colombian media has dubbed this latest political scandal the "Yidis-política."

On the evening of Thursday, June 26, President Uribe called a rushed press conference in reaction to the decision by Colombia's Supreme Court on the case of Yidis Medina: a guilty verdict. The court found that Medina did in fact cast her vote in exchange for political favours. She will spend three and a half years under house arrest for accepting bribes from the president. The Court's statement on the case called into question the very legitimacy of the process that led to Uribe's re-election. The president responded, on national television, that the justices who questioned the re-election process are doing the bidding of terrorists and called on the Colombian Congress to schedule a national referendum to repeat the 2006 elections.

State paramilitarism

"Paramilitarism is a strategy of the state," confessed former paramilitary boss Salvatore Mancuso in an interview, a policy of which, according to his testimony, he is living proof. Up to the time of his confession there appeared to be no problem. The real problem arose, rather, when Mancuso began to talk about paramilitarism as a strategy of the state for the benefit of transnational capital: a strategy that would, on the one hand, guarantee land and cheap labor for the implementation of megaprojects through forced displacement; and on the other hand, provide the security apparatus necessary for the protection of such an excellent comparative advantage.

It was at that point that Mancuso needed to be silenced and was subsequently extradited to the United States – not to pay for his crimes, which included massacres directed against the Colombian people from which multinational corporations directly benefited. The extradition of Mancuso halted any hope for the families of the victims in receiving their rights to truth and reparations, as U.S. justice will only judge him on charges related to narcotrafficking.

Canada also negotiated with a country with one of the world's worst human rights records; violence has been perpetrated against human rights defenders, members of opposition political parties and social movements, trade unionists, students, rural peasants and indigenous peoples who are opposed to an illegitimate regime and its policies.

Development for whom? Canada and FTAs in Latin America

Today, Canada presents itself in Latin America as a "Third Way," differing from the models offered by the United States and Venezuela. Is this true? A look at the Free Trade Agreements being drawn up for Latin America may bring one to the conclusion that each new trade agreement is progressively more damaging for these countries.

The FTA between Colombia and Canada has been negotiated in secret; but one can assume that it is a carbon copy of the FTA signed by Colombia and the U.S., rejected by the U.S. Congress for the innumerable violations of human rights perpetrated in Colombia by the state.

These agreements function within the discourses of "development" and "win-win situations." Analyzing this fallacy of development and democracy through the experience of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), it is revealed that the Mexico that exists outside the bubble of Cancún "develops" only greater levels of poverty and misery.

Similarly, Mexican democracy itself has become something of a joke, given the inauguration of "President" Calderon, who was brought to power through stolen elections.

With the Canada-Colombia FTA, what is at play is the Canadian government's decision to define its foreign policy and what kind of development and democracy it favours. By ratifying this FTA, Canadians would become complicit in the crimes perpetrated by the illegitimate regime of Uribe, Harper's close "ally."

The decision to sign the FTA with Colombia for the benefit of private interests above the interests of the general public will aggravate the dismal situation of hunger, health care and education in Colombia, exacerbating the known social problems that stem from it.

The logic of accumulation promoted by these agreements is one that benefits transnational capital to the detriment of peoples. If this is Canada's foreign policy, its people and the world should be made aware. By presenting itself as a "Third Way," as something better than the model offered by the U.S. or Europe, Canada is hiding the true meaning of the FTA, as they are all equally damaging and ill-fated for the people.

Moreover, the supposed "good name" of Canada on the world stage is being manipulated to push particular readings of development and democracy. What do they look like? Well, they are no different than those exported by the United States.

Canada, in approving the FTA with Colombia, will have to decide which model of "development" it will promote: development for people, or for transnational corporations?

Now more than ever, experience has taught us that this system is unsustainable in terms of the environment, the economy, food and human security and political inclusion. It is our right and obligation to construct a new model that will guarantee the survival of the planet and of humanity.

This will only be possible if it is done in an inclusive manner, if we form one united chorus, with all our voices and experiences and find the strength necessary to produce the results we want and need.

Finally, we must remember that the closing of the Colombia-Canada FTA negotiations does not represent ratification of this bilateral agreement. We invite the people of Colombia and Canada and the different social, political, student, union, rural, indigenous and women’s organizations to mobilize immediately to reject this agreement, an agreement that works against people and for the benefit transnational corporate interests.

We – as people who believe in the possibility and need to create a more just world and work for solidarity, inclusion, social justice and the protection of life – have the democratic right to demand that this dangerous agreement is not signed by our governments.

Augusto Bohórquez is a Colombian writer based in Canada.

EL QUE NO CONOCE LA HISTORIA...

Por: Gabriel Bustamante Peña

Apenas comenzó su primera candidatura no alcanzaba el 2% en las encuestas, y su propuesta no fue lanzada desde ningún partido tradicional que pudiera vaticinar una posterior fuerza electoral para disputar la presidencia. Sin embargo, su discurso antipolítico y anticorrupción, pero principalmente fuerte contra una guerrilla asesina, terrorista y sin rumbo político, le gestó un impresionante ascenso de popularidad. Una sociedad cansada de los abusos criminales a los que se había reducido el proyecto beligerante y una asfixia en los intentos de solución política fueron la clave de su arrollador éxito con el que llegó por primera vez a dirigir el destino de la nación.

Realizó su primer gobierno, no sin antes reformar la Constitución para permitir su propia reelección. Y a pesar de no haber cumplido su promesa de acabar el terrorismo en su primer período, sus golpes a la guerrilla fueron tan contundentes que llegó a acorralarlos, a capturar o dar de baja a gran parte de sus cabecillas, disminuyendo de forma drástica su accionar violento en todo el país.

De la mano con la lucha antiterrorista vino también la recuperación económica y la inversión extranjera. Fue reelecto por una amplia ventaja y su imagen favorable llegó a estar cerca al 80% y nunca por debajo del 70%. Y todo esto, a pesar de los grandes escándalos de corrupción y de violaciones a los derechos humanos de los que se acusaba a su gobierno. El efecto teflón que generó, le permitió pasar incólume por encima de los crímenes de lesa humanidad y los actos probados de descomposición política que se gestaron ensu administración.

Los escándalos de corrupción comenzaron a cercar sus principales círculos de poder, llegando a sus principales asesores y al Congreso, el cual se vio afectado por una de las principales crisis de ilegitimidad en su historia.

Nuevamente, el envilecimiento político venía desde el Gobierno, pero la gente aislaba la imagen presidencial de este episodio que hedía como nunca a podredumbre. Y no contento con una reelección, comenzó a planear comoquedarse en el poder. Pero esta vez, no sólo por gusto sino por necesidad: el miedo a un futuro juzgamiento lo convirtió en beneficiario y víctima de su propio trono.

Su discurso, cada vez más agresivo, se enfiló contra la oposición política y social a la cual estigmatizó y ridiculizó aprovechando los múltiples espacios oficiales. Generó un ambiente de polarización y recurrió a investirse como el representante de un patriotismo indiscutible, de tal forma que, quien estuviera contra él estaba contra el país y debía ser considerado terrorista.

Mantuvo a los medios de comunicación bajo su poder a través de concubinatos empresariales o por medio del chantaje que ejercía sobre ellos y elaboró toda una maquinaria de propaganda oficial para magnificar su imagen.

Gobernó acaparando todo el poder, a través del desequilibrio institucional que generó su propia reelección. Permitió que la corrupción infiltrara al Estado como nunca antes se había dado en el país y llevó a la moral pública a la más profunda de su crisis. De la misma forma, captó a las fuerzas militares como su ejército propio, utilizándolas para sus intereses, no pocas veces contrarios a la dignidad humana.

Confundió popularidad con legitimidad y por esta vía pasó por encima de la ley y de la constitución. Atacó al poder judicial con una saña tal que llegó a acusarlo de ser enemigo de la democracia y se enfrentó personalmente a la justicia hasta llegar a doblegarla.

Finalmente, tras 11 años en el poder y ya sin el paraguas de la guerrilla, la lluvia de escándalos le hicieron huir del país y pasó a ser declarado 'moralmente insubsistente' por el Congreso. Hoy, Alberto Fujimori está preso y enfrenta procesos por crímenes de lesa humanidad y corrupción. Crímenes que cometió bajo el apoyo ciego de una sociedad sedienta de venganza y mano dura y en la ausencia de la sana crítica y la oposición política, que diferencian a las verdaderas democracias de las dañinas y falaces tiranías de las mayorías.

Espero que no hayan pensado que el escrito se refería a nuestro presidente y 'patrono' Álvaro Uribe.... porque él y Fujimori no tienen absolutamente nada en común...

July 1, 2008

The Uribe Government and Democratic Security Advance with Guns and Machetes in Northern Cauca, Colombia


Written by The Association of Indigenous Authorities of Northern Cauca (ACIN),
Originally published in NASA-ACIN, July 1, 2008
Translated by Micheal O Tuathail for La Chiva

As the traditional indigenous authority of Northern Cauca, the council of the Association of Indigenous Authorities of Northern Cauca (ACIN) REPORTS to and ALERTS the national and international community that members of the public forces – police, army and ESMAD [Colombia’s version of a SWAT team] – have attacked 80 indigenous people with bullets and machetes after finding them at the Las Pirámides farm, located in the municipality of Santander de Quilichao, while engaged in the Ritual of the Liberation of Mother Earth.

In a serious act of contempt for human rights, soldiers unleashed their hate on the community, which was in the act of pacifically Liberating Mother Earth, wounding two indigenous men with bullets and machetes. One of the wounded is MARINO CAMAYO, a well-respected and widely known indigenous leader, serving as governor of the Las Delicias reserve, ex-councillor of the Cauca Regional Indigenous Council (CRIC), ex-coordinator of the ACIN’s health program and ex-mayoral candidate in Buenos Aires, Cauca. After having been captured, insulted and beaten, he is currently in Francisco de Paula Hospital in Santander de Quilichao being treated for severe blows to his body, wounds to his face and head from being clubbed and kicked, and machete gashes in his right knee.

Leaving him gravely wounded was not enough for the aggressors: they have since begun the process of pressing charges against him for demanding the right to land. Similarly, ALBEIRO CAMAYO, coordinator of the Indigenous Guard, is at the same hospital receiving treatment for a bullet wound to his left leg.

In response to these violent events, we reject the Uribe government’s ‘Democratic Security Policy’ and the carrying out of Phase II of Plan Colombia, which converts indigenous territories into a theatre of operations where the public forces execute the orders of their higher-ups and attack the defenseless civil population, violating human rights and international humanitarian law.

We call upon human rights defenders, humanitarian organizations, NGOs and the international community to accompany us by clarifying these facts and demand that the government’s impunity for acts like these – so evidently directed against the civil and indigenous population – cease to continue. We also ask that they remain alert in response to the actions of the public forces against the community’s legitimate processes, such as the Ritual of the Liberation of Mother Earth.

ASSOCIATION OF INDIGENOUS AUTHORITIES OF NORTHERN CAUCA
Santander de Quilichao, Cauca, Colombia, July 1, 2008.
http://www.nasaacin.org/noticias.htm?x=8115


Tejido of Communication and External Relations for Life and Truth
Association of Indigenous Authorities of Northern Cauca - ACIN
Telefax: 0928 - 290958 - 293999
Email: acincauca@yahoo.es
Web: www.nasaacin.org
Santander de Quilichao, Cauca - Colombia

Harper’s Free Trade Mantra: Hush, Rush, and Sign

By Dawn Paley, Originally published in Upside Down World, 1 July, 2008

Image
Nov. 2007 Protest in Toronto

This January, after little more than 6 months of negotiations, the Canadian Government announced the completion of negotiations of the Canada-Peru Free Trade Agreement at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland.

Six months later, on June 7, 2008, Canada announced that negotiations for a controversial Free Trade Agreement (FTA) with Colombia were finalized.


The negotiations with Colombia were controversial from the get go: the country has the worst human rights record in the hemisphere, and the government of Alvaro Uribe is riddled by ongoing scandals that have revealed proven links between Uribe’s allies in Congress and paramilitary death squads.


In a corruption scandal that would most certainly bring down a Canadian Prime Minister, Uribe himself is the subject of a recent Sentence by the Colombian Supreme Court. The justices condemned him for buying the key vote of Congresswoman Yidis Medina in exchange for political favours, a crime necessary for the constitutional changes that opened the door to Uribe’s re-election in 2006.


On June 26th, Medina was sentenced to 3 ½ years of house arrest for accepting bribes from the president. The president promptly responded that the justices were doing the bidding of terrorists and (illegally) called for a referendum for the repeat of the 2006 elections.


Compared to the deal with Colombia, which has begun to generate concern among Colombians and Canadians, Canada’s agreement with Peru slid in under the radar. It was ratified on May 29th, making it the country’s fourth with a Latin American country: first came the Canada-US FTA in 1988, which integrated Mexico with the implementation of NAFTA 1994, then an agreement with Chile signed in 1997, and another with Costa Rica ratified in 2002.


Signed, Sealed and Delivered?


On July 7, 2007, the Conservative government of Stephen Harper announced the beginning of FTA negotiations with Peru and Colombia, having identified the two countries as prime targets for the signing of Free Trade Agreements in accordance with the economic plan Advantage Canada.


Both of the agreements were negotiated rapidly and in behind closed doors. According to Mario Valencia from the Colombian Network in Response to Free Trade (RECALCA), "almost no one here knew that Colombia was negotiating with Canada."


The negotiations "were extraordinarily fast, and unlike the negotiations with the United States, which lasted 16 rounds, they were wrapped up in the fifth round of negotiations, out of the six rounds planned at the outset in July of 2007," according to a press release put out by RECALCA.


So fast, in fact, that the end of Canadian negotiations with Colombia was announced before the Standing Committee on International Trade had finished the report they were preparing to advise the government during negotiations.


"By making this announcement only days before the Standing Committee on International Trade report would have been completed, the government is clearly saying that it does not respect the work of Parliament," stated Liberal International Trade Critic Navdeep Bains. [1]


The report, meant to "guide negotiations," was released more than 2 weeks after they were concluded. It contains eight recommendations, of which the second "recommends that the Government of Canada maintain close ties with Colombia without signing a free trade agreement..." [2]


The Conservatives have not made a statement with respect to the Canada-Colombia Free Trade Agreement since Canadian Minister of Foreign Affairs and International Trade David Emerson announced the finalization of negotiations. In Canada, there is no need for a vote in parliament to ratify the agreement, unlike in the United States, where the Democrat led congress has thus far ‘frozen’ the ratification of the US-Colombia Free Trade Agreement partly due to concerns about human rights in Colombia.


According to Colombian activist and physician Manuel Rozental, "The Harper Government knows what it is doing and that even Parliament would not approve the process, content and impacts of the agreement, hence the ‘rush and hush’ strategy."


When asked what message he would like to send to the Conservatives, Rozental responded bluntly: "No deal with a criminal regime."


ImageCanada’s Business Sector: Precious Interests


The mining sector, along with the financial and oil and gas sectors, is among the major Canadian business interests in Latin America.


"Mining is the single activity in which Latin America and the Caribbean is the most prominent region for Canadian Outward Foreign Direct Investment," reads a recent report from the UN’s Economic Commission for Latin America. [3]


Chile, the world’s largest producer of copper, was the first Latin American country to sign a bilateral Free Trade Agreement with Canada.


In a presentation to the International Trade Committee, Trade Minister David Emerson explained that after the Canada-Chile Free Trade Agreement was signed, "Canadian mining companies in particular invested massively in Chile, [and] brought the resource or semi-processed resource product out of Chile into Canada... creating a stronger mining sector and opportunities for value added in the Canadian economy." [4]


In Colombia and Peru, the majority of Canadian investment is in the extractive industries.


Peru is an extreme case. In 2006, the top five exports from Peru to Canada break down as follows: gold made up 57.5%, raw copper accounted for 10.8%, refined copper for 8.7%, zinc for 8.1%, and unleaded gasoline for 6.0%. [5]


A large part of the production of these raw materials exported from Peru to Canada is in the hands of Canadian companies, including Barrick Gold, Yamana Gold, Teck Cominco and Iberian Minerals Corporation.


More than two thirds of the estimated $3 billion invested by Canadian companies in Colombia is in the extractives sector. The Canadian companies with the largest estimated investments in Colombia in 2007 include Nexen Inc and Petrobank Energy and Resources, both based in Calgary, and Toronto’s Pacific Rubiales Energy.


The on-going armed conflict in Colombia, combined with a history of small-scale mining activity, has thus far prevented the country from being transformed into a metallic metal producer on par with Peru, but that trend is changing, and fast. South African gold giant Anglo Gold Ashanti and their partners have secured more than 10 million hectares in mineral concessions in Colombia since 2004.


Colombia is already a major producer of coal, and new changes in the Mining Law as well as President Uribe’s policy of ‘Democratic Security’ and guarantees to trans-national companies, are being made to facilitate the start up of large-scale, metallic mining projects in Colombia.


Canadian junior mining companies are present in scores. Of note are B2Gold Corp, Bandera Gold Ltd., Blue Sky Uranium Corp, Colombia Goldfields, Greystar Resources, Latin American Minerals, and Mega Uranium Ltd, all of which are carrying out exploration for gold or uranium.


Mining Industry Pushes for Protection


The push for Free Trade Agreements has been strong from businesses and business lobbies representing the extractive industries. At a presentation on Canadian mining investment on March 6, 2005, Christian Côté from International Trade Canada pointed out to his audience that there exists "pressure from natural resource community for government to improve investment climate for target countries." [6]


Canadian companies stand to benefit from Free Trade Agreements because they remove the possibility that host governments will raise taxes, change their laws, or expropriate properties.


By way of example, the FTA with Peru eliminates the possibility that Peru would enact such a thing as the recent "Mining Mandate" passed in Ecuador by the Constituent Assembly, which suspends all large scale mining activity (exploration) in Ecuador for 180 days while a new Mining Law is written.


According to Foreign Affairs Canada "An investment chapter in the Canada-Peru FTA locks in market access for Canadian investors in Peru and provides greater stability, transparency and protection for their investments." [7]


These elements have little to do with popular conceptions of "Free Trade" as the lowering of tariffs and taxes. In the words of Colombian economist Héctor Mondragon, "these agreements should be known as ‘Agreements on the Rights of Trans-national Corporations’ instead of as ‘Free Trade Agreements.’"


The day that the negotiations of the Free Trade Agreement with Peru concluded, the Mining Association of Canada (MAC) sent out a press release stating "MAC strongly supported the commencement of these negotiations and is very pleased to see them concluded in such a timely manner." [8]


Lobbying by industry in favour of an agreement with Colombia continues. In mid-May, the Canadian Chamber of Commerce sent a letter to Lee Richardson, the Chair of the Standing Committee on International Trade, to "strongly encourage [the] committee to endorse these negotiations and the benefits that they will bring to Canadian companies and to Canadians." Eight companies signed on in support of the letter, including Barrick Gold Inc, Teck Cominco, Nexen Inc. and Talisman Energy. [9]


Where do Canadians Stand?


In Canada, the Harper government and the mainstream media bombard the population with the idea that Free Trade Agreements are about prosperity, economic growth, security, equitability, and democracy. A cursory look at the facts shows us that these agreements negotiated and signed in complete secrecy, actually best represent the wishes of large corporations, and lack even a token amount of democratic participation.


Will Canadians stand by and allow the Harper government to ratify a Free Trade agreement with Colombia, where 24 unionists were killed and four disappeared in the first 4 months of 2008, so that Canadian mining and oil companies can make more money? Or will Canadians stand up in defence of life and speak out against these agreements, negotiated with one of the most repressive regimes in the hemisphere and in their names but without their consent?


Together, perhaps, these are the key questions in determining the moral compass of Canadians as Parliament resumes again in September.


Notes:


[1]Liberal Party of Canada. (June 9. 2008). Colombian Deal Shows No Respect for Parliament. Retrieved June 28, 2008 from www.liberal.ca/story_14058_e.aspx


[2] Standing Committee on International Trade. (June, 2008). HUMAN RIGHTS, THE ENVIRONMENT AND FREE TRADE WITH COLOMBIA Report of the Standing Committee on International Trade Retrieved June 28, 2008 from http://cmte.parl.gc.ca/cmte/CommitteePublication.aspx?SourceId=245001


[3] Economic Commission for Latin America (May, 2008). Foreign Investment in Latin America and the Caribbean 2007, Chapter IV- Canadian FDI in Latin America and the Caribbean. Retrieved June 29, 2008 from this link.


[4] Standing Committee on International Trade. (December 4, 2007). EVIDENCE

Tuesday, December 4, 2007. Retrieved June 29, 2008 from http://tinyurl.com/5dqe42


[5] Ministerio de Comercio Exterior y Turismo. (May, 2007). Reporte de Comercio Bilateral: Perú-Canada. Retrieved June 29, 2008 from http://www.mincetur.gob.pe/newweb/Portals/0/comercio/tlc_canada/estudios.html


[6] Côté, Christian. (March 9. 2005.) Canadian Mining Investment in Russia and Central Asia. Retrieved June 29, 2008 from http://www.nrcan.gc.ca/mms/invest/2005/rus/pdf/cote.pdf


[7] Foreign Affairs Canada. (May, 2008). Fact Sheet: Investment. Retrieved June 29, 2008 from this link


[8] Mining Association of Canada. (January 26, 2008). MAC Applauds Canada-Peru Free Trade Agreement. Retrieved June 29, 2008 from http://www.mining.ca/www/media_lib/Press_Release/2008/01_29_08.pdf


[9] Beatty, Pearrin. (May 16, 2008). Re: Study of Status of the Free Trade Agreements and ongoing Negotiation between Canada and Colombia. Canadian Chamber of Commerce. Retrieved June 29, 2008 from http://www.chamber.ca/cmslib/general/RichardsonColombiaFTAsupportletter.pdf


Dawn Paley is a journalist based in Vancouver, BC. She is currently in Colombia.


McCain Heads To Colombia, Already Tied To Country By Lobbyists

By Sam Stein, Originally published in The Huffington Post, 1 July, 2008

On Tuesday, Sen. John McCain will travel to Colombia to highlight his support for a free trade pact with that country.

It is a trip that comes with a share of political risk. While the Arizona Republican is hoping to showcase his command of the world stage, his venture south of the border raises concerns from those opposed to his trade policies. Already, his position as an independent arbitrator on Colombia - a country often criticized for its labor and human rights practices - is undermined by a bevy of advisers who have earned large amounts either lobbying for the Colombia Free Trade Agreement, or representing corporations that do business with that country.

On some occasions, these companies have been linked to the killings of union workers and other civilians, sometimes in collusion with Colombia's government or allied paramilitary groups.

McCain's chief political adviser, Charlie Black, represented the oil-giant Occidental Petroleum from 2001 through 2007, in the process earning $1.6 million in fees for his firm, according to lobbying records. Among the issues on which he lobbied included the Colombia Free Trade Agreement (though also general energy topics concerning Middle East countries). Occidental gained a certain amount of political infamy when its security company was accused of bombing a Colombian village and killing 17 civilians in 1998. The company, which works with the country's military forces to protect an oil pipeline, denied involvement in the attack. But in 2007, Occidental again found itself in the midst of a human-rights mess, this time accused in congressional testimony of being "complicit" - with several other major corporations - in the murder of three labor leaders.

Black isn't the only McCain confidante with connections to companies pushing for free trade with Colombia. Kirk Blalock, a bundler who has raised at least $250,000 for the Senator, lobbied on behalf of American Forest & Paper Association, Ford Motor company, General Pharmaceutical Association, and Miller Brewing, all of which have championed the Colombia Free Trade Agreement.

Peter Madigan, another top fundraiser for the presumptive GOP nominee, was described as a lobbyist who "works for the government of Colombia" to "promote a U.S.-Colombia free-trade agreement" by ABC News. A lobbyist at Johnson, Madigan, Peck, Boland & Stewart, Madigan's clients include Philip Morris, Arthur Andersen, Charles Schwab, Goldman Sachs, Shell Oil and Verizon. His firm, ABC wrote, has "distributed papers defending Colombian President Alvaro Uribe against allegations of ties to paramilitary groups, and promoting the controversial anti-drug program 'Plan Colombia' as achieving 'strengthening human rights.'"

Meanwhile, Susan Nelson, McCain's finance director, and Tom Loeffler, the recently resigned national finance chairman, both lobbied in the past for the Colombia FTA on behalf of Footwear Distributors and Retailers of America. In the process they earned tens of thousands of dollars for their firm, The Loeffler Group.

"It seems that McCain's entire brain trust is pushing for these trade deals," said Bill Holland, deputy director of Global Trade Watch. "And after the primaries, when we have seen that Americans are overwhelming rejecting the current model, to have all these advisers pushing it is a bad sign."

McCain himself seemed to acknowledge that improvements were needed in the Colombian government's human rights record during a press conference on Monday. But he cast President Uribe's moves in targeting and cracking down on labor leaders and political foes as functions of his goverment's broader, more noble, battle against domestic terrorism.

The U.S. should not "throw out the entire theory of free trade" aside, said the Senator. "Failure to ratify the free trade agreement sends a message throughout the hemisphere: If you're a friend of the United States, don't count on them."

But prominent labor figures and progressives in the United States -- not to mention opponents of free trade -- contend that it is a U.S. imperative to persuade Colombia to adjust its labor laws. Citing the murder of 39 trade unionists in 2007 (and more than 2,500 such deaths since 1986), they argue that companies that do business in Colombia, and those that use the government's military arm to protect their position, "bear an enormous responsibility" for these abuses. And that it would be hard for any president to persuade these corporations if their lobbyists are on the payroll.

"It is unconscionable that American companies would essentially buy into the system of terror that the paramilitary organizations are inflicting on the country," said Thea Lee, Policy Director at AFL-CIO. "We would certainly call on any American company operating in the country not to team up with the paramilitaries.

"This whole idea that [McCain] goes down to Colombia to show himself as a great statesman and he won't say anything critical of the Uribe government, and he has staffers who are paid lobbyists for some of the companies guilty in this discussion, I can't imagine who is advising him on this strategy."